On night one Miss Indiana America 2009 Katie Stam and Miss Delaware Galen Giaccone were chosen as the Miss America 2009 Lifestyle and Fitness winner and Miss America 2009 Talent winner Katie Stam Miss Indiana America 2009 was the Miss Lifestyle and Fitness winner On night two Miss Georgia America 2009 Chastity Hardman was named Wednesday night s Miss America 2009 Talent